5 Worst Gold and Silver Buys for Investors (and What to Buy Instead)

The worst gold and silver buys for investors are products where most of what you pay is markup rather than metal: TV-advertised commemorative and plated coins, proof and 'semi-numismatic' coins, very small gram bars bought in bulk, financed or 'stored-for-you' metal from unregulated sellers, and bullion from online marketplaces where fakes circulate. Regulators have taken action against firms charging markups of 50–130%. The safer alternative is plain bullion — 1 oz sovereign coins and LBMA bars bought close to spot.
1. TV 'commemorative', colourised and plated coins
Advertised as limited editions or 'collector' pieces, these are often privately made medallions or plated base metal. The US Mint says it does not make privately colourised coins and has warned that 'replica' sellers are not affiliated with it. In 2025 a US federal court ordered Safeguard Metals to pay about $51 million in restitution and penalties after regulators said it sold overpriced coins to older investors with undisclosed markups; Red Rock Secured was accused of markups of 100–130% while telling customers 1–5%.
- Red flags: cold calls, 'free gift' offers, pressure to switch retirement savings, fees not stated in writing.
- Buy instead: 1 oz sovereign bullion coins priced openly from spot.
2. Proof and 'semi-numismatic' coins as an investment
Proof coins are beautiful, but you pay heavily for the finish and the packaging. The CFTC calls 'semi-numismatic' 'a made-up industry term' and says a hard push to sell such coins is likely a scam; it notes numismatic coins are often sold at 40–200% over spot and bought back for a fraction of that. Unless you are a collector who plans to hold for many years, the premium rarely comes back.
- Buy instead: the bullion version of the same coin — the gold content is identical.
3. Stacking tiny gram bars
A 1 g bar can cost 15–30% over spot, against roughly 2–5% for a 1 oz bar. Twenty 1 g bars cost far more than a single 20 g bar — and far more again than an ounce. Small bars make lovely gifts; they're an expensive way to build a position.
- Buy instead: the largest piece your budget allows — see what gold to buy with $1,000–$50,000.
4. Financed, leveraged or 'stored-for-you' metal from unregulated sellers
Since 2011 US law treats financed or leveraged retail metals deals as illegal off-exchange transactions unless the metal is actually delivered within 28 days. The CFTC warns that some firms in these schemes never bought the metal at all — while charging customers storage and insurance fees on it. Gold IRA pitches deserve the same caution: the CFTC cites cases where fees and markups took a third to half of investors' savings.
- Buy instead: metal delivered to you, or allocated storage with a named, audited vault. See allocated vs unallocated gold.
5. Bullion from online marketplaces
As prices climbed, fakes followed. Australian authorities warned in 2025 about counterfeit bars copying Perth Mint packaging, police found 'gold' sold on Facebook Marketplace was gold-plated copper and plastic, and a US dealer survey found most dealers had been offered fake PAMP bars. Buying from strangers online removes every safeguard.
- Buy instead: a dealer that sources directly from mints and LBMA refiners and sells sealed products. See how to spot fake gold and silver.
Honourable mention: jewellery as an investment
14-carat jewellery is about 58% gold, and the retail price includes design and markup. Selling usually returns well under what you paid. Buy jewellery to wear; buy bullion to invest.
A quick checklist before any purchase
- Work out the metal value: weight × purity × spot.
- Compare the price to that value — 1 oz bullion should be within a few percent.
- Ask what the dealer would pay you back today.
- Make sure you receive the metal, or know exactly where it's stored.
- Buy recognised products from a dealer that sources from mints and LBMA refiners.
Ready to convert crypto into gold?
Buy investment-grade gold and silver with Bitcoin, priced live to the market and shipped fully insured.
Shop bullionFrequently asked questions
Are proof coins a good investment?
What does 'semi-numismatic' mean?
Why is a 1 g gold bar so expensive per ounce?
Are TV-advertised commemorative coins worth anything?
Is it safe to buy gold on eBay or Facebook Marketplace?
What's a fair premium over spot?
This article is for general information only and is not financial advice. Precious-metal and cryptocurrency prices can fall as well as rise. Do your own research and consider speaking to a licensed advisor before investing.
Related reading

How to Spot Fake Gold & Silver: The 2026 Testing Guide
The tests that actually work for checking gold and silver at home, why tungsten fakes beat most of them, the professional tools that catch them, and the simplest way to never buy a fake.
Read article →
What Happens If Your Bullion Dealer Goes Bust?
When a bullion dealer collapses, some customers lose everything and others lose nothing. The difference is not luck — it comes down to whether you took possession.
Read article →
How to Buy Gold Online Safely: A 2026 Buyer's Guide to Avoiding Scams
Buying gold online is safe — if you know what to look for. The red flags, the checks, and how to buy bullion with confidence.
Read article →